OPINION: WHILE the housing correction has been headed off, with Australian housing remaining very expensive it's hard to see the housing bubble starting up again.
Introduction
It seems that Australian house prices have defied fears of big declines in the wake of sharp falls in US and UK house prices. My expectation was for national capital city average house prices to fall 10% or so this year. After falling 6% or so from their peak around the beginning of 2008 to the March quarter this year, house prices have since started to recover again with
Why the resilience?
Despite Australian house prices having had a stronger run up than those in the US and UK, they have fared remarkably well by comparison over the last couple of years. From their peaks US house prices have fallen 32% and UK house prices have fallen 19%.
Source: Case-Shiller, Nationwide,
By comparison, Australian house prices have only had a modest dip and seem to be already on the way back up. Several considerations explain the relative resilience of the Australian housing market. These include Australia’s housing shortage as well as the fact lending standards were far higher in Australia than in the US with the surge in debt focused on older wealthier Australians and the use of full recourse loans in Australia which provide a powerful incentive to keep servicing a mortgage even when the value of the debt exceeds the home value.
These considerations, along with the view that Australia was not going to have US style recession, led us to reject the view that house prices would fall 30 to 40% as some were suggesting. Rather, we thought that prices might fall 10% or so, but even this now looks too pessimistic. The big surprise has been that Australia’s economic downturn has turned out to be even more modest than earlier thought. The economy is yet to have a technical recession and the rise in unemployment has been mild. As such, the generational lows in mortgage rates & the increase in first home owner grants have dominated the housing market.
Outlook
While house prices seem to have turned the corner, we find it hard to see a return to boom time conditions. The positives are that affordability is much improved (see the next chart), Australia is still suffering from a housing shortage and the upswing in most housing related indicators such as auction clearance rates and housing finance suggest that confidence has returned to home buyers – both owner occupiers and investors and at the top end as well as the bottom end of the market.
Source: Commonwealth Bank/HIA. REIA, AMP Capital Investors
Against this, several factors are likely to constrain the upswing in house prices. Firstly, despite the correction over the last 18 months Australian housing remains expensive.
In real terms, Australian house prices remain well above their long term trend. Over the last 80 years the trend rate of growth in real house prices has been 3% per annum, which is consistent with long term real
Source: ABS, AMP Capital Investors
Australian housing remains expensive by global standards with a ratio of house prices to median household income roughly double that in the US.
Source: Wendell Cox and Hugh Pavletich, 5th Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey: 2009, AMP Capital Investors
Despite strong growth in rents, rental yields remain low. Gross rental yields of around 5% are well below the 7% plus net rental yields available on directly held commercial property, the 10% distribution yields on listed property trusts and a grossed up dividend yield of 7% from Australian shares.
Secondly, the improvement in affordability has been mainly been driven by lower mortgage rates and hence could vanish pretty quickly if interest rates go back up again, leaving many of those who got in recently somewhat vulnerable. This contrasts with the US and UK where a surge in affordability has been mainly driven by the collapse in house prices.
Thirdly, while less of a threat than feared unemployment is still trending up and poses a constraint on house prices. Historically, rising unemployment has been associated with falls in real house prices. See next chart.
Finally, the ending of the first home owners boost from December will also act as a dampener on the lower end of the housing market. These considerations suggest that while a US style collapse has been averted, house prices are unlikely to just go back into boom territory. The more likely scenario is that house prices grow but at a rate below that of nominal incomes such that the ratio of house prices to incomes gradually continues to decline.
Source: Thomson Financial, REIA, AMP Capital Investors
That said, given Australia’s history with house price bubbles and that much of this can be traced to restrictive land release policies, the risk of another unsustainable surge cannot be ignored. The downside though is that, having dodged a bullet this time, given Australia’s very high household debt to income ratio, it would leave Australia very vulnerable to the next global economic downturn.
Housing as an investment
History suggests that once proper allowance is made for costs, residential investment property and shares generate a similar long term return. This is illustrated in the next chart, which shows an estimate of the long term return from housing, shares, bonds and cash since 1926.
Source: ABS, REIA, Global Financial Data, AMP Capital Investors
Over the long term, the returns from housing and shares tend to cycle around each other at similar levels. In fact, both have returned an average of 11.5% pa over the last 80 years or so. While housing is less volatile than shares and for many seems safer, it offers a lower level of liquidity and a low level of diversification. The bottom line is that once the similar returns of housing and shares are allowed for, and these characteristics are traded off, there is a case for both in investors’ portfolios over the long term. Right now after the second worst bear market in the Australia’s share market history and with the yield on shares running well above the yield on housing property, shares are arguably a better short term bet.
Concluding comments
Thanks to a housing shortage, less problems with credit quality and a far milder than expected economic downturn, Australian house prices have proven to be pretty resilient. While they now appear to be on the way up again, a return to boom time conditions seems unlikely. Over the very long term residential investment and shares have provided similar returns and so there is a role for both in an investment portfolio.
By Dr Shane Oliver, head of investment strategy and chief economist AMP Capital Investors.*
Australian Property Journal
